What's wrong with this proof of 1 = 2?

Obviously 1 does not equal 2, but this ``proof'' is discussed from time to time:

$\displaystyle a$ $\displaystyle = b$    
$\displaystyle ab$ $\displaystyle = b^2$   Multiply both sides by $ b$ .    
$\displaystyle ab-a^2$ $\displaystyle = b^2-a^2$   Subtract $ a^2$ from both sides.    
$\displaystyle a(b-a)$ $\displaystyle = (b+a)(b-a)$   Factor    
$\displaystyle a$ $\displaystyle = b+a$   Divide both sides by $ b-a$ .    
$\displaystyle a$ $\displaystyle = 2a$   Since $ b+a=2a$ .    
$\displaystyle 1$ $\displaystyle = 2$   Divide both sides by $ a$ .    

The erroneous step was dividing both sides by $ b-a$ , which was dividing by 0 since $ a=b\Leftrightarrow b-a=0$ . There are other (equally invalid) ways to prove $ 1=2$ .


aah@ryan-usa.com
Giganews Newsgroups